Feature
Steel Sheet Piles
Soldier Pile & Lagging Walls
Concrete Walls
Best Use Cases
Waterfronts, flood zones, tight urban sites
Temporary excavations, highways, deep cuts
Permanent retaining walls, high-load applications
Waterproofing
Excellent (interlocking design)
Limited (gaps between lagging)
Good (if properly sealed)
Installation Speed
Fast, but requires specialized equipment
Moderate, simpler equipment
Slow (formwork, curing time)
Flexibility
Moderate (prefabricated sections)
High (custom spacing and lagging materials)
Low (rigid structure)
Reusability
High (can be extracted and reused)
Moderate (steel beams reusable, lagging often not)
Low
Cost
Moderate to high
Generally lower
High
Durability
High with corrosion protection
Moderate (depends on lagging material)
High
In short:
Soil Condition
Recommended System
Loose or Granular Soil
Steel sheet piles (excellent for cohesionless soils), reinforced soil walls with geogrid
Cohesive Soil (Clay)
Soldier piles with lagging, secant or diaphragm walls if water is present
High Water Table
Steel sheet piles, diaphragm walls, or secant piles with dewatering systems
Rocky Soil
Anchored systems, rock bolts, or cast-in-place concrete walls
Soft/Compressible Soil
Reinforced soil walls, geogrid-reinforced embankments, or deep foundations
Key Considerations:
Recommended System:
Steel Sheet Piles would be ideal here. Why?
If the soil were clayey and you had more space, soldier piles with lagging might be more cost-effective. Or if you needed a permanent, watertight wall in a high-risk zone, secant piles or diaphragm walls would be the go-to.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.